Between 2006 and 2012, major banks foreclosed on thousands of military families—many while the servicemember was deployed overseas.

The foreclosures were illegal. The banks knew the law. They did it anyway.

When federal regulators finally caught up, the settlements exceeded $123 million. Here's the full story.

What the Law Says

Under 50 U.S.C. § 3953, a creditor cannot foreclose on a servicemember's primary residence without a court order. This protection applies:

  • During the entire period of military service
  • For one year after military service ends

The court must:

  1. Determine whether the servicemember's ability to pay is materially affected by military service
  2. Appoint an attorney if the servicemember isn't represented
  3. Stay proceedings if military service is impacting the member's ability to appear

This isn't a minor technicality. It's a fundamental protection that prevents servicemembers from losing their homes while serving their country.

The Banks' Response: Ignore It

During the housing crisis of 2008-2012, banks foreclosed at unprecedented rates. In the rush to process foreclosures, SCRA compliance became an afterthought—or was ignored entirely.

Internal bank documents later revealed:

  • Employees were evaluated on foreclosure volume, not compliance
  • SCRA checks were cursory or nonexistent
  • Military status verification was not integrated into foreclosure workflows
  • When violations were discovered, some banks chose to proceed anyway

The Settlements

JPMorgan Chase: $31 Million

Chase foreclosed on servicemembers without obtaining court orders or verifying military status. The DOJ found:

  • Active-duty servicemembers lost their homes during deployment
  • Chase did not check the DoD SCRA database before proceeding
  • Violations were systematic, not isolated

Chase paid $31 million in restitution and penalties. Some families received their homes back. Others received cash settlements.

Bank of America: $39 Million (Foreclosure) + $30 Million (Other)

Bank of America's foreclosure machine was even larger. The DOJ found:

  • Widespread failure to verify military status
  • Foreclosures on servicemembers serving overseas
  • Failure to appoint attorneys as required by law
  • Interest rate violations across mortgage products

The foreclosure-specific settlement was $39 million. Combined with other SCRA violations (interest rates, mortgage servicing), Bank of America's total exceeded $69 million.

Wells Fargo: $28.4 Million

Wells Fargo's foreclosure violations mirrored the others:

  • Foreclosures without court orders
  • No military status verification
  • Servicemembers came home from deployment to find their homes sold

Wells Fargo paid $28.4 million and agreed to reform their processes. (This was before their subsequent SCRA violations for auto repossessions and interest rates, which pushed their total past $87 million.)

Saxon Mortgage: $2.35 Million

Saxon Mortgage, a smaller servicer, was caught with similar violations. The settlement required:

  • Restitution to affected servicemembers
  • Compliance monitoring
  • Process reforms

Other Banks

Additional settlements and enforcement actions hit:

  • Citi Mortgage
  • HSBC
  • PNC
  • Numerous smaller servicers

The total across all institutions exceeded $123 million in direct SCRA foreclosure-related penalties and restitution.

How This Happened at Scale

1. The Robo-Signing Scandal

During the foreclosure crisis, banks employed "robo-signers"—employees who signed thousands of foreclosure documents per day without reviewing them. SCRA compliance checks were often skipped entirely.

2. Volume Over Compliance

Bank employees were evaluated on how many foreclosures they processed, not whether those foreclosures were legal. SCRA verification slowed the process, so it was deprioritized.

3. Weak Internal Controls

Banks claimed they had SCRA compliance programs. Investigations revealed these programs were inadequate:

  • Database checks weren't performed consistently
  • Results weren't reviewed properly
  • Violations weren't escalated
  • Nobody was held accountable

4. Assumption of Impunity

For years, banks faced minimal consequences for SCRA violations. Many calculated that the cost of compliance exceeded the risk of enforcement.

The $123+ million in settlements changed that calculation.

Families Caught in the Middle

Behind the statistics are real families:

  • The Marine deployed to Iraq who received a letter in a combat zone informing him his house was being auctioned. By the time he could respond, it was sold.
  • The Army family who discovered their foreclosure when they returned from a 3-year overseas assignment. The bank had sold their home while they were serving in Germany.
  • The Navy spouse who tried to stop a foreclosure while her husband was on deployment. The bank proceeded anyway, claiming they "couldn't verify" his military status.

These aren't hypotheticals. These are the cases documented in DOJ complaints.

What Changed

The settlements forced systemic changes:

Mandatory SCRA Database Checks

Banks must now verify military status through the DoD's SCRA database before initiating foreclosure. This should have been standard practice—it wasn't until enforcement actions forced it.

Dedicated SCRA Compliance Teams

Major banks now have dedicated teams handling SCRA requests and compliance. These teams didn't exist before the enforcement wave.

Regulatory Oversight

OCC, CFPB, and DOJ now actively monitor SCRA compliance. Banks submit regular reports and face audits.

Private Enforcement

The settlements created templates for private litigation. Servicemembers can now more easily sue for SCRA violations, with attorney fees recoverable under the statute.

If You Were Affected

If you experienced a foreclosure during military service:

Check the Timeline

  • Was the foreclosure initiated during active duty?
  • Did the bank obtain a court order?
  • Were you represented by an attorney in court?
  • Was the foreclosure completed within one year after your service ended?

If the answer to any of these is problematic, the foreclosure may have been illegal.

Request Your File

Contact your former mortgage servicer and request:

  • Complete foreclosure documentation
  • Records of any SCRA verification
  • Court filings (if any)

Consult a JAG Attorney

Base legal assistance can review your case and advise on options. For complex cases, they can refer you to civilian attorneys who specialize in SCRA litigation.

Check Settlement Records

Some settlement funds went unclaimed. If you were affected by Chase, Bank of America, or Wells Fargo foreclosures during this period, check whether you're entitled to restitution.

Current Protections

The law hasn't changed—50 U.S.C. § 3953 still protects your home:

  • During service: Cannot foreclose without court order
  • One year after service: Same protection continues
  • Mortgage interest: Capped at 6% for pre-service mortgages

If a lender threatens foreclosure, know your rights. The banks paid $123+ million to learn this lesson. You don't have to be their next victim.

Sources: